Opinion | Shrinking Civic Space and Democratic Challenges in Balochistan

Balochistan is the largest province in Pakistan, yet many people there feel that their rights and freedoms are under threat. In recent years, civic space, the space for people to speak, organise, protest and participate in politics, has been shrinking. This has made it harder for citizens and groups to voice their concerns and work for change.

One of the major reasons why civic spaces are shrinking is the criminalisation of peaceful activism. In 2025 and more recently, the Pakistani government added many Baloch activists to the terrorist watchlist under the anti-terrorism law. However, the Baloch activists were only calling for their rights and justice peacefully. These laws limit their movements and make it difficult for the activists to move around.

Many Baloch activists have also been detained or arrested simply for protesting or speaking out about disappearances and killings in their communities. Amnesty International and other human rights groups have criticised these detentions as unfair and a violation of basic rights like freedom of expression and peaceful assembly.

Journalists and media workers in Balochistan also face pressure and censorship. Media platforms and social media are sometimes blocked or monitored, making it harder for reporters to cover protests or human rights issues without fear of retaliation.

The impact of these restrictions is quite visible in the realm of political mobilization. If people are not able to organize meetings or protests or express themselves, the level of trust in the democratic process will be undermined. The people of Balochistan feel that their voices are not being heard or recognized, and this is making them even more dissatisfied with the political process. If they are not able to express themselves, they will not be able to bring about a change in the decisions that affect them.

Civic space means the freedom to speak out, join groups, protest peacefully and take part in democratic life. In Balochistan today, these freedoms are increasingly restricted.

Many human rights groups and activists face intimidation or charges. People who speak out are often accused of posing security threats. Media persons face intimidation, pressure, and even self-censorship. In some cases, they may not write or report on sensitive issues due to fear of reprisals. Large protests, rallies, or strikes may be prevented or hindered by the authorities. Activists and political organizers may be detained.

According to the human rights groups, overall civic space in Pakistan is rated as ‘repressed’, meaning that many basic democratic freedoms are restricted. These include limitations on peaceful protests, restrictions on speech, and criminalisation of dissenting voices.

There are a number of factors that are leading to the closing of democratic spaces in Balochistan.

Security policies: The first Key factor in this regard is the security policies of the government. The government is more inclined towards military policies rather than political policies.

Another factor is the existence of Laws that allow long detention. Some legal provisions permit security forces to detain people for longer without proper judicial oversight, leaving activists, journalists and political opponents vulnerable to abuse.

Fear and distrust also play an important role. Many people fear taking part in politics openly because they fear arrest, disappearance, or harassment.

When civic space shrinks, political participation and public trust suffer. People lose faith in elections and political processes. If elections are seen as unfair or if political parties cannot organise freely, many citizens feel that their voices do not matter.

Political groups find it hard to mobilise. For nationalist or human rights groups, it has become difficult to arrange meetings or campaigns, which has impacted negatively on collective political action. Therefore, alienation has increased, particularly among the youth. When the youth feel that their issues cannot be addressed through peaceful politics, they may become alienated.

Civic space is essential for a healthy democracy. When citizens have the freedom to speak, organise, and protest, governments are more accountable and responsive to public needs. However, when this space closes, trust between citizens and the state weakens, political resentment increases, and opportunities for dialogue and peaceful resolution of grievances diminish.

Shrinking civic space affects individual rights and the future of democratic engagement in Balochistan. For meaningful change to occur, many experts say that freedoms must be protected and civic voices allowed to be heard in public and political life.

In recent years, Balochistan has also been facing serious conflict and human rights problems. Armed violence between the Pakistani state and separatist groups like the Balochistan Liberation Army (BLA) continues. Recently, there were major militant attacks in the province that killed many civilians and security personnel, and the United Nations Security Council condemned these violent events.

As a result, the military operations conducted by the military killed hundreds of militants but resulted in the loss of civilian lives and damage to the local infrastructure.

On the other hand, the civic space and the level of political freedoms are declining. There is the alleged forced disappearance, arrests, and suppression of human rights defenders and peaceful protestors. Reports from human rights organisations show that many people, including students, activists, women, and ordinary citizens, have gone missing in recent years, and families still do not know the whereabouts of many of them.

Peaceful protest movements have often been met with police harassment, arbitrary arrests, internet restrictions, and legal pressure. Human rights groups have called for an end to the crackdown on Baloch activists and demanded the release of detained leaders.

This is because of the combination of violence, repression, and political restrictions. In this context, it has become unsafe for people to raise their voices or become part of politics in Balochistan. It has become unsafe for common citizens to speak to the authorities or protest against the government.

In conclusion, present-day Balochistan is marked by ongoing conflict, serious human rights violations, and a shrinking space for civic. These conditions make it increasingly difficult for people to express their views freely and work together for peaceful change.

faizajaan181118@gmail.com